Talk:Ashley Magnus

Her status
Ashley's status is currently listed as "Alive" despite the fact she is dead (and it even lists a death date right below here status).


 * Please do two things before you comment.


 * 1 - Sign your post with four tildes (~).


 * 2 - Read the page. It is confirmed that she is alive.
 * --Fullmetal Fan (talk) (Contribs) 05:46, November 20, 2010 (UTC)

Should it be listed as unknown? I feel it should be becuase we haven't seen a body also there's never been any confirmation so wouldn't just be better to list her as unknown?MrAnonymous (talk) (Contribs) 05:30, June 21, 2011 (UTC)MrAnonymous


 * If her status is listed as unknown all remarks that refer to as dead without a doubt would have to be changed. The show treats her as dead. She is listed as having a date of death. IMO her status should be listed as dead. If she is ever resurrected or proven to have never died it can be changed then. --Revan&#39;s Exile (talk) (Contribs) 05:52, June 21, 2011 (UTC)


 * I agree. Sci Fi shows resurrect people all the time, so we should stick with what the show currently says about the status of a person, not what might be some day. Ambiguities can be addressed in the "background" section. Right now, I think we should be more careful about all those rumors floating around; although the Ashley lovers would obviously love to have her back, there is absolutely no in-universe information stating that she is alive, and all fan speculation concerning a possible return of Emilie Ullerup to the show has proven completely false so far.
 * Don't get me wrong, I'd love to have her back too ( Ashley-Kate cat fight - meow! ), but right now there is no rational reason to list her as alive. -- SaganamiFan (talk) (Contribs) 08:53, June 21, 2011 (UTC)


 * I just recently added that there indeed was a plan to bring Ashley back for Season 5 as stated by Amanda Tapping in a Dever Starfest 2014 interview (I accidentally didn't realize that I wasn't signed in when I edited the page, so it just says a wiki contributor.)  In all honestly, I myself had always assumed that she did (what mother wouldn't try?), just that we never got to see it. It does makes sense, as I always wondered about how Helen had removed all of the abnormals within a very short amount of time underneath everyones noses until Nikola notices right before Helen self destructs the Old City Sanctuary. My hopeful thought was that Ashley teleported them out just a few minutes prior and then returned one last time to pick up Helen at the last possible second. I highly criticize the fact that Helen survived not only the explosive blast, but also the extreme heat and the weight of tons of stone & metal falling down on top of her. That's even considering if she had Henry's FOSSS jacket on correctly, to which she didn't and there physically was not enough time for her to put her left arm through the other sleeve on and zip it up completely before the bombs detonated. Ashley being alive can also be an easy explaination as to how Magnus got into her bedroom undetected near the end of 4x02 "Uprising". As far as Ashley's status goes, I'm a little unsure about changing it from Deceased to Alive, as even though we have a "confirmation" that she was set to return off-screen, it still wasn't shown on-screen. I feel that the limbo of Unknown would be more appropriate. --X20ArchAngel09x (talk) (Contribs) 21:04, December 30, 2015 (UTC)